SJ' Warehouse

Even more important, however, and certainly more generally applicable, is the argument from queerness. 어쩌면 더욱 중요하고 그리고 확실히 더 일반적으로 적용가능한 것이 기이성 논증(논변)이다. If there were objective values, then would be entities or qualities or relations of a very strange sort, utterly different from anything else in the universe. 만일 객관적 가치가 있다면, 그것은 매우 특이한, 즉 우주의 어떤 것과도 완전히 다른 종류의 실체이거나 성질 또는 관계일 것이다.

2015-2. ‘Moral judgements commit us to the existence of irreducibly non-natural, mind-independent moral facts. But on our best understanding of the world, such facts do not exist. Therefore, all moral judgements are false.’ Is this a sound argument? The text enclosed in quotation marks in the body of this question paraphrases (without quoting directly) one of J.L. Mackie’s most famous arguments ..